Ranking higher on Google is mostly four things, in this order
Open a private browser window and search for the thing you sell plus your city. Roofer Escondido. Dentist Oceanside. Barber near me.
If you are not in the first three results on the map, that is the problem worth fixing. Everything else is a distant second.
Most of what gets written about ranking on Google is aimed at businesses selling to the whole country. You are not that. You serve people within driving distance, and that changes almost everything about what works.
There are two Googles, and you probably only need one
A local search returns two different sets of results. There is the map, with three businesses, a pin and a row of star ratings. Below it are the ordinary blue links.
The map is where local buying happens. Someone searching for an emergency plumber is not reading an article. They are looking at three names, checking the stars, and tapping call.
Those two sets of results are ranked by different things. The map draws almost entirely on your Google Business Profile, your reviews, and how near you are to the person searching. The blue links draw on your website. Spend a year improving your website while ignoring your profile and you can climb the blue links without moving an inch on the map.
One: your Google Business Profile, filled in completely
It is free, it takes an afternoon, and it is the biggest lever most local businesses have never pulled.
- The primary category has to be exactly right. Not close. A roofing contractor listed as a general contractor is running in the wrong race. Pick the most specific category that describes what you do, then add secondary ones for the rest.
- Hours, including holidays. An unanswered "are these hours still right?" prompt is a signal that nobody is minding the listing.
- Services listed one by one. Each one gives Google another phrase to match you against.
- Photographs, added regularly. Not a logo and one stock photo from 2021. Real jobs, real premises, real people.
- A service area if you travel to customers. And if you work from a home address, hide it. A hidden address with a service area is the correct setup, not a penalty.
None of this is clever. That is rather the point. The businesses sitting above you in the map are rarely doing anything sophisticated. They filled in the form.
Two: reviews, and recent ones specifically
Review count matters. Recency matters more than most people expect, and it is where nearly everyone loses ground.
A business with 200 reviews whose newest is fourteen months old reads as a business that has stopped. A business with 40 reviews and three from this month reads as busy. The ranking and the human deciding between you are reacting to the same signal.
So aim for a steady trickle rather than a burst. Five a month, every month, beats forty in one week followed by silence.
Reviews are not a project you finish. They are a tap you leave slightly open.
Reply to them, including the bad ones. A calm, specific reply to a one-star review does more for the next person reading than the review itself costs you.
Three: pages that match what people actually type
This is the website half, and the mistake is nearly always the same. The site has one page called Services that lists nine things.
Nobody searches for "services". They search for "tile roof repair Vista" or "emergency AC repair Temecula". If a phrase is worth real money to you, it needs a page of its own that is genuinely about that phrase.
That page should cover what the job involves, what it tends to cost or what the cost depends on, how long it takes, what to do next, and ideally show one you have finished. Written for a person rather than for a search engine. Those two things stopped being different some time ago.
One warning, because this is the failure we see most. A page per service multiplied by a page per town becomes forty thin pages carrying the same sentence with the city swapped out. Google is good at spotting that pattern and it counts against you. Fewer pages with genuinely different content beats a directory of near-duplicates every time.
Four: being described the same way everywhere else
Your name, address and phone number sit in a lot of places you did not create. Apple Maps, Yelp, Facebook, the chamber of commerce, old directories, a supplier's "where to buy" page.
When those disagree, Google has to decide which version is true, and uncertainty is not rewarded. An old suite number or a phone line you gave up four years ago is doing quiet damage.
Fixing it is unglamorous admin. Find the listings, make them match, and pay particular attention to the phone number. If you have changed your number recently this matters more than anything else on this list.
Four things that do not work
- Stuffing city names into your footer. It stopped working more than a decade ago and it makes the page worse to read.
- Buying links. Wasted money at best, a manual penalty to dig yourself out of at worst.
- Blogging with no particular purpose. Posts written so that something has been posted do nothing. Posts answering the question a buyer asks the week before they call can do a great deal.
- Chasing a city you are nowhere near. Proximity is a real factor in the map and you cannot optimise your way across forty miles. You can compete in the blue links there. The map will stay difficult.
How to tell whether any of it worked
Do not check by searching for yourself. Google knows roughly where you are and what you usually click, and it will show you a flattering result that nobody else is seeing.
Use Search Console instead. It is free, it takes about ten minutes to connect, and it tells you which phrases you already appear for and roughly where you sit. The useful discovery is almost always the same one: you are already on page one or two for a handful of phrases you never deliberately targeted, and pushing those up is far easier than starting from nothing.
Then watch calls and form fills rather than positions. Position is a proxy. The phone ringing is the actual thing.